The Dark Side to Falling Oil Prices

The slump in oil prices could stifle global growth and force some oil-dependent economies into recession.

December 04, 2014    |    By Scott Minerd

Global CIO Commentary by Scott Minerd

The price of oil is the overriding economic theme at the moment. Oil prices have declined to their lowest level in more than four years and I believe they could continue to tumble. The market implications are positive in the near term, but there is a dark side to the decline in oil prices that is beginning to negatively impact a number of countries around the world and which could ultimately come home to roost in the United States.

First, the positive: falling oil prices and the subsequent decline in gasoline prices act like a tax cut, transferring cash into the pockets of consumers, leaving more money for discretionary spending. The combined benefit of declining gas prices and lower interest rates is likely to provide American consumers, and subsequently the U.S. economy, with a boost as we head into the all-important holiday shopping season.

The darker side to falling oil prices is that they signal that the global economy isn’t growing fast enough to absorb the growth in oil production. The slump in oil prices has led to a weakening in the currencies of some major oil-exporting nations. Russia, for example, has witnessed a 24 percent decline in the value of the ruble against the dollar since the beginning of November. Russia needs oil at $100 a barrel to support its economy, and many other oil-dependent economies rely on oil prices well north of current levels. Over time, as foreign currency reserves run dry, the likelihood is that we will see economic contraction and possibly recession in these countries.

A recession in countries such as Russia will have significant knock-on effects, particularly for European exporters, creating another headwind for beleaguered euro zone economies. An oil-price-induced negative feedback loop would stifle global growth and could even lead to political instability in any number of oil-dependent nations.

Beginning as early as the first quarter of 2015, investors should be wary of the potential for a setback in U.S. equities as the adverse impacts of lower growth and weaker foreign currencies begin to show through in the results of leading multinational companies.

In Europe, it doesn’t seem likely the European Central Bank is going to be able to reach the necessary consensus to begin quantitative easing through the purchasing of sovereign debt until the end of the first quarter or possibly into the second quarter, and perhaps never. ECB President Mario Draghi is running into roadblocks with the German Bundesbank over the sovereign bond-buying option, which will probably end up in the European courts. The problem is, the longer this situation drags on, the worse the situation in Europe is going to get. The clock is ticking and policymakers are running out of time.

One option the ECB still has left is to buy gold. If European inflation data comes in weaker and the European economy continues to sputter, I think we could see the ECB consider gold purchases, but if we do it will be an act of desperation. Gold may prove the ultimate hedge against a financial crisis in Europe should the ECB fail to act quickly.

The Bright Side: Cheaper Gas, Rising Consumer Confidence Should Boost U.S. Holiday Spending

Despite the drop in consumer spending during the Black Friday weekend, the outlook for consumption remains solid heading into the holiday shopping season. Historically, Black Friday sales have had little predictive value for total holiday season sales. A more important relationship is between gasoline prices and consumer confidence, and then between consumer confidence and holiday sales. With gas prices at their lowest levels since 2010, consumer confidence has jumped to seven-year highs, and higher consumer confidence predicts higher holiday sales. Increased consumer confidence, combined with additional discretionary income freed up by falling gas prices, should provide a boost to economic growth in the fourth quarter.

Gas Prices and Consumer Confidence


Source: Bloomberg, Haver, Guggenheim Investments. Data as of 11/28/2014. Note on methodology: The estimated change in consumer confidence is based on monthly retail gasoline prices and University of Michigan consumer confidence. The holiday sales estimate is based on the average reading of the University of Michigan consumer confidence index in November and December and retail sales excluding autos, gas, and building materials in November and December. All data since 1994.

Economic Data Releases

ISM Readings Signal Continued Strength in U.S. Economy

  • The ISM manufacturing index continued its strong expansion in November, although the reading ticked down to 58.7 from 59.0.
  • The ISM non-manufacturing index jumped to 59.3 in November, a three-month high.
  • Durable goods orders beat expectations in October, rising 0.4 percent. However, the less volatile component of non-defense capital goods orders, excluding aircraft, dropped 1.3 percent, the same decline as the previous month.
  • New home sales inched up in October, increasing 0.7 percent to an annualized pace of 458,000. The prior two months were revised downward.
  • Pending home sales decreased 1.1 percent in October, following September’s 0.6 percent gain.
  • Construction spending rose 1.1 percent in October, a five-month high.
  • University of Michigan consumer confidence was revised down slightly in the final November reading to 88.8, but remained at a post-recession high.
  • Initial jobless claims jumped to 313,000 for the week ended Nov. 22, up from 292,000.
  • The core Personal Consumption Expenditures deflator, the Fed’s preferred inflation gauge, ticked up to 1.6 percent in October after five months at 1.5 percent.

Euro Zone Disinflation Continues, Chinese Data Is Mixed

  • The euro zone manufacturing Purchasing Managers Index decreased to 50.1 in the final November reading, a 17-month low.
  • The euro zone services PMI was revised lower in the second November estimate, falling to an 11-month low of 51.1.
  • Euro zone economic confidence improved for a second consecutive month in November, inching up to 100.8 from 100.7.
  • Euro zone retail sales increased 0.4 percent in October, slightly under expectations.
  • The euro zone-wide Consumer Price Index ticked back down to 0.3 percent in November, while core prices remained at 0.7 percent.
  • Germany’s manufacturing PMI was revised into contraction in the final November estimate at 49.5, the lowest level since June 2013.
  • Germany’s GfK consumer confidence continued to rebound in the December reading, ticking up to 8.7.
  • Retail sales in Germany surprised to the upside in the October reading, up 1.9 percent.
  • Germany’s CPI fell to 0.5 percent in November, the lowest since February 2010.
  • U.K. third-quarter GDP rose in line with expectations at 0.7 percent. Consumer spending had the best quarter in over four years, while exports and investment fell.
  • China’s official manufacturing PMI fell to 50.3 in November, the second consecutive slowdown.
  • China’s non-manufacturing PMI ticked up to 53.9 in November from 53.8, following two months of declines.
  • Japan’s CPI fell for a fifth straight month in October, down to 2.9 percent from 3.0 percent. Prices excluding food and energy fell to 2.2 percent.
  • Japanese industrial production beat estimates in October, rising 0.2 percent after a 2.9 percent gain in September.


September 17, 2019

Forecasting the Next Recession: Will Rate Cuts Be Enough?

History shows that once our recession forecast model reaches current levels, aggressive policy can delay recession, but not avoid it.

August 22, 2019

Looking Past the Liquidity-Driven Rally

Credit spreads could get tighter in this liquidity-driven rally, but history has shown that the potential for widening from here is much greater.

July 29, 2019

The Fed's Sugar High

Rational immigration policy, not rate cuts, is the way to avoid recession.


Third Quarter 2019 Fixed-Income Outlook 

Third Quarter 2019 Fixed-Income Outlook

Portfolio Manager Adam Bloch and Matt Bush, a Director in the Macroeconomic and Investment Research Group, share insights from the third quarter 2019 Fixed-Income Outlook.

Core Fixed-Income Conundrum 

Solving the Core Conundrum

Anne Walsh, Chief Investment Officer for Fixed Income, shares insights on the fixed-income market and explains the Guggenheim approach to solving the Core Conundrum.

Read a prospectus and summary prospectus (if available) carefully before investing. It contains the investment objective, risks charges, expenses and the other information, which should be considered carefully before investing. To obtain a prospectus and summary prospectus (if available) click here or call 800.820.0888.

Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.

Guggenheim Investments represents the following affiliated investment management businesses of Guggenheim Partners, LLC: Guggenheim Partners Investment Management, LLC, Security Investors, LLC, Guggenheim Funds Investment Advisors, LLC, Guggenheim Funds Distributors, LLC, GS GAMMA Advisors, LLC, Guggenheim Partners Europe Limited and Guggenheim Partners India Management. Securities offered through Guggenheim Funds Distributors, LLC, an affiliate of Guggenheim, SI, GFIA and GPIM.

© Guggenheim Investments. All rights reserved.

Research our firm with FINRA Broker Check.

• Not FDIC Insured • No Bank Guarantee • May Lose Value

This website is directed to and intended for use by citizens or residents of the United States of America only. The material provided on this website is not intended as a recommendation or as investment advice of any kind, including in connection with rollovers, transfers, and distributions. Such material is not provided in a fiduciary capacity, may not be relied upon for or in connection with the making of investment decisions, and does not constitute a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell securities. All content has been provided for informational or educational purposes only and is not intended to be and should not be construed as legal or tax advice and/or a legal opinion. Always consult a financial, tax and/or legal professional regarding your specific situation. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal.